The #1936 Club: The Poisoners by George R. Preedy

The year is 1678 . The Sun King Louis XIV graces the throne of France. Perhaps the greatest European king of his generation, Louis’ rule epitomizes the Reign of Absolutism. But while his own people and other European nations are in awe of his court, his millitary success, his generous patronage of the Arts…scandal is just round the corner.

“You notice my dear Desgrez, that in this investigation we come upon a good number of widows.”

Lieutinant Charles Desgraz has recently come to Paris from Normandy. Part of the best policing-force of Europe, Desgraz wants to rise high in the ranks because of his own ambitions and his desire to make his newly-wedded wife, Salonge, wealthy and comfortable. When the novel opens, Charles and Salonge are on their way to the house of a friend who is celebrating Salonge’s birthday. Over there, a woman, Widow Bosse, is drunk enough to let out certain indiscretions about her business which seems to be about providing poison to wives who are tired of their husbands.

When Desgraz conveys this to M. de La Reynie, the Chief of Police, the man is not impressed. Two years before, in 1676, Madame de Brinvilliers had been burnt at the stakes for the murder of her family by the poison obtained through her lover Sainte-Croixe and an aquaintance of his, the Italian Exili. After that the priests round Paris had reported to the police of hearing confessions from women of having murdered their husbands. The Police Chief was not interested however and dismissed these as hysteria and derangements. He thinks Widow Bosse too is one of those women.

The ambitious Desgraz, however, thinks that this case might be his ticket to further promotions and decides to trap Widow Bosse with the help of his wife. What begins with a drunkan remark soon snowballs into a conspiracy of gigantic proportions, the network running through the mean streets of Paris to aristocratic houses to even the places of Royalty. The miasma of evil includes poison making, counterfeiting, infanticide, witchcraft, Satanism with all its obscene rituals. Nobody – from the humblest wife tired of a controlling aged husband to renowned generals to the maîtresse-en-titre, the Marquise of Montespan herself -is free from taint.

As panic spreads:

Silver utensils had gone out of fashion, save for those wealthy enough to carry their own cases of knives, forks and cutlery; glasses, plates and dishes were cleaned at table, charming bouquets of flowers and innocent-looking dishes of luscious fruit were regarded with horrible suspicion; a woman feared to handle her Mass book, a man to touch his rosary; as every day fresh arrests were made, the alarm, and horror grew; universal distrust was abroad

Desgraz and Reynie realise that there is one brain working behind all this. the man who is called the Great Author/ Master and who in a note explains his lust for power to the Police Chief:

You do not realize the joy it is to be God and Satan in one—to destroy for the love of destruction, for lust or greed or ambition, as one wishes! You cannot understand the superb sense of power it gives me to walk modestly, unnoticed, perhaps despised, and to know that I have power even over Kings!

This is an interesting historical mystery which had me transported to the intrigues of 17th Century France. However much time may have passed since then certain things are extremely contemporary:

“Is it possible for us to bring these people to justice?” asked Desgrez eagerly.

“I do not think so. I should not dare to take any steps until I have asked the King.”

Desgrez made a gesture of vexation.

“It is hard,” he said bitterly, “to unearth these criminals and then find they are protected by the very highest in the land.”

Also I liked the contrast that the author draws between marriage based on love and support as that of Salonge and Charles and the love affairs of King Louis XIV which despite all the power that he has at hand leave him with feelings of guilt, self-loathing, and even terror. And the thoughts of Madame de Maintenon as she offers advice to the king chilled me to the core.

The novel is peopled with both real and fictional characters. My favourite was the real life figure of Gabriel Nicolas de la Reynie often considered to be the founder of the first modern police force. The pragmatic chief who knows that any moment his own life can be forfeit if he dares to dig the dirt too deep yet doggedly carries out his duties:

The Chief of Police, liberal-minded by nature, had long since learned a complete, detached tolerance, and the rather tiresome fanaticism and unbending austerity of Pignata wearied him; there was something unnatural in the bigotry of one so young…


This is the third book that I have read connected to L’affaire des poisons or The Affair of the Poisons after John Dickson Carr’s The Burning Court and E.T.A. Hoffmann’s Mille de Scuderi. I’d like to read more on this. Any suggestions?


First Line: As the coach came swinging round the corner the young man pushed his companion still further behind him and held out his cloak in an effort to protect her, but in vain, the wheels of the vehicle, which was swinging heavily on its leathers, splashed over the broken cobbles and cast a shower of liquid filth over the girl’s camelot dress of blue and silver.

First published: 1936

Source: Project Gutenberg Australia

Other Opinions: She Reads Novels

Other books read of the same author: Aunt Beardie, The Crime of Laura Sarelle

13 thoughts on “The #1936 Club: The Poisoners by George R. Preedy

  1. That line you share certainly does resonate today, Neeru! I suppose some things don’t change… The story sounds like a very interesting look at the France of the Sun King, And it’s interesting to consider how it impacts society to have an absolute monarch. The mystery sounds intriguing, too, and I can see how you were engaged with it.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Margot, actually Louis XIV doesn’t come across as an absolute monarch! Poor fellow, he is shaken and terrified by the conspiracies all around him. And I envisaged a bitter future for him with Madame de Maintenon:)

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I read a mystery which vaguely touches on L’affaire des poisonsThe Mystery of the Boule Cabinet I think it’s available for free at Internet Archive. It’s certainly old enough (1912) to be free somewhere on the internet. I have enjoyed Bowen’s historical mysteries, most of which were written under her other male pen name “Joseph Shearing.” I read one book by her as “George R. Preedy” — <A href=";The Devil Snar’d, a nasty and cruel crime novel with a smidgen of a ghost story element. Loved it, of course!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. In my comment above if you pass you cursor over the title of The Mystery in the Boule Cabinet above it will reveal a hyperlink to my review. But I messed up on the second hyperlink. A typo in the HTML code now makes it appear in text. But if you pass over the text that appears as a URL and click it will appear in a browser window. Then all you need to do is delete this portion: &quot Then click again and the review will appear.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. This is a time period I have not read about so should probably read this some time. I don’t recognize the author’s name but possibly read about some of her books elsewhere. She wrote a lot of books.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. She is better known as Marjorie Bowen and yes did she write a lot!! All the three books that I have read of her have been very good. I plan to read more of her. If you read any of hers I’d love to read your reviews.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.