Friday’s Forgotten Book: The Mouse who wouldn’t play Ball by Anthony Gilbert (1943)

“One of them did it, of course,” he told himself, “but we shall never know which, so what the hell?”

A tense figure waits near a staircase, in anticipation. Suddenly there is a cry of fire and panicked figures come running out of the dark, converging near the staircase. A candle is lighted but before its flickering light can reveal anything, it falls down. There is a scream in the darkness as a figure tumbles down the stairs. When a torch is finally procured and switched on, the body of miser-millionaire, Everard Hope, lies at the bottom of the spare. It seems, he had caught his foot in a hole in the worn-out carpet and went tumbling down. But did it really happen like that? The home is full of his relatives who all wanted something out of Uncle Hope’s fortune: the lawyer Garth and his socialite-wife, Lucille; the Lacey brothers: Christopher and Hugh; the unimpressive writer Cecil and his sensible wife, Lilias. And then there is the housemaid-secretary, Julia. It seems Uncle Everard had summoned his lawyer and wanted to change his will but somebody didn’t want it.

When the will is finally read, the family is in for a shock. The money has gone to the eponymous mouse but with a caveat (Uncle Everard’s nasty joke): The mouse will only inherit if it remains alive, thirty days after the reading of the will. With the relations facing financial and other problems for which money is needed, how long will the mouse survive? Thankfully Arthur Crook is around.

This is vintage Gilbert. I always enjoy Gilbert not merely for the mystery but also for her characters and humour. And she is in such fine form in this novel. I could guess the culprit (though I was never cent percent sure) but that didn’t take away from the enjoyment of the novel. The humour, esp in Gilbert’s use of metaphor and similes, and a host of complex, interesting characters made the book totally riveting. And my sympathies were for all the persons concerned. The end was pretty satisfying too. Another thing that I liked was the description of war without any bitterness or demonising of the Germans. All in all, a book that needs to be republished.

Have you read it? Do you rate it highly too?


First Line: In the Icy long-dark house someone waited for zero hour.

Publication Details: 1943. London: Collins (The Crime Club), 1943.

Series: Arthur Crook #12

Alternate Title: 30 Days to Live

Pages: 192

Other Opinions: Pretty Sinister Books

Trivia: Made into a movie, Candles at Nine, in 1944.

Other books read of the same author: (Among Others): Treason in My Breast

18 thoughts on “Friday’s Forgotten Book: The Mouse who wouldn’t play Ball by Anthony Gilbert (1943)

  1. This is a really effective setup for a novel, Neeru. I can see how it would appeal so much. And I do enjoy some wit in what I read. I’ve always thought it takes special skill to weave just enough wit into a story without taking away from the story, if that makes sense.

    Liked by 1 person

          1. Thanks Neeru. I was looking up the Miles Burton books the other day and only then found that Miles Burton, John Rhode and Cecil Waye were all pen names of Cecil Street–very prolific.


  2. Neeru, my review of THE BANGALORE DETECTIVES CLUB will be posted to my blog (http:\\ tomorrow, Sunday, June 5, 2022. I found the setting and mystery intriguing!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.