Three Vintage Mysteries

With little time to spare nowadays, here are brief reactions to reading of three mysteries.


The question that perplexed me after finishing Lorac’s Bats in the Belfry was that how could a novel that began so promisingly, that had me gripped almost its entire length, end on such a pathetic note. To pin a murder on somebody without giving any inkling of his/her family history (which is what leads to the murder) is definitely not what one expects from a mystery. And some of the coincidences near about the end are just too much – car going up in flames, man slipping down the stairs and grievously injuring himself, car developing a snag. Also some of the threads do not get tied up: Who fiddled with the seals? Why was the murderer in a panic and staging a getaway? Disappointing.

First Line: “As funerals go, it was quite a snappy effort.”

Publication Details: London: Collins (The Crime Club), 1937

First Published: 1937

Series: Robert Macdonald #13

Other books read of the same author: (Among others) Black Beadle



Again a novel that begins extremely well with a man being blackmailed on account of his wife’s past. However, Mason is overbearing in this one and with my sympathies with a character whom Mason did not like, it became hard reading. My favourite character was an operative of Paul Drake, and a woman who I hope would leave everything behind and start life anew. The identity of the murderer surprises one and there is an interesting scene b/w Tragg, Della, and Perry but yet I did not like this.

First Line: STEWART G. BEDFORD ENTERED HIS PRIVATE OFFICE, HUNG up his hat, walked across to the huge walnut desk which had been a birthday present from his wife a year ago, and eased himself into the swivel chair.

Publication Details: NY: Pocket Books, 1959

First Published: 1956

Pages: 180

Series: Perry Mason #50

Other books read of the same author (Among others): The Case of the Baited Hook



I have not come across many American novels that deal with the question of class (and admittedly my reading of American literature is very limited) so reading this novel by Potts was a novel experience. Potts once again writes a gripping story of the vanities, pettiness, generosity of small-town America. Reading the last sentence filled me with visceral hatred against a character I had liked till then. Over all, this is a tragic story of the unsuccessful quest to belong.

First Line: Evan had forgotten about the wind.

Publication Details: NY: Dell Publishing, 1958

First Published: 1958

Other books read of the same author: (Among others): The Little Lie


Have you read these books? What was your reaction to them?

9 thoughts on “Three Vintage Mysteries

  1. Sorry to see that two of these didn’t live up to expectations, Neeru. Still, the last sounds very good. And it does sound like an interesting perspective on class issues.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. The only one I’ve read is Bats in the Belfry and I loved it! Must admit the details of the plot have vanished from my mind now, but I remember it giving a great depiction of London and creating quite a spooky atmosphere, and I enjoyed the two young characters who kind of operate as amateur ‘tecs alongside MacDonald. Having since read more of her books, I wouldn’t say this is the best of them, but I’m sorry you found it so disappointing.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Yes, FF, till about the end, I too found it (as mentioned above) a great read. However, the ending, completely destroyed the novel for me. Too many cousins popping out of nowhere, too many coincidences…. perhaps I am so disappointed because the set-up was so great. But I am glad you enjoyed it. 😀


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.