Wolf! Wolf!: Anthony Gilbert’s Lady-Killer

Anthony Gilbert was one of the finds of last year. It is thus appropriate that the first mystery read this year be of hers. Anthony Gilbert was the pseudonym of  Lucy Beatrice Malleson and she was born almost at the fag end of the 19th century, in 1899. Her first published novel was The Man who was London in 1925 under the name of J. Kilmeny Keith. As Anthony Gilbert, her first published work was The Tragedy at Freyne (1927). Her protagonist was Scot Egerton, who went on to solve crimes in 10 more novels. But in 1936, appeared Arthur Crook, a lawyer with a penchant for wearing loud clothes and quite unlike the aristocrat detectives of those days. Murder by Experts (1936) was so well-liked that he appeared in 50 more books.

Lady-Killer is the 25th book of Crook’s. Unlike the other two that I have read of Gilbert’s, Lady-Killer is more in the mould of a thriller than a mystery. We know right from the beginning who the criminal is, the question is whether Crook will be able to apprehend the man before he is able to do another dastardly deed.

Henry’s vocation is being a husband. Like the famous English king with whom he shares his first name, Henry  first woos, then weds, and then kills his wives (after taking away their property, of course). Unknown to him though is the fact that a London lawyer Arthur Crook has taken note of the fact that many women whose husbands have the initial H. G. have died in unfortunate circumstances.

And then Henry falls in love with an orphan Sarah. She is impish, energetic, and liable to act without thinking of the consequences. Henry takes her to a lonely cottage and initially she is just happy to have Henry but slowly uncomfortable questions rise in her mind. But cut off as she is from the rest of the world, would any help reach her before Henry decides that she has become a little too inquisitive for her own good?

This being a post WW II novel, it was interesting to see how the position of women had changed as regards their venturing out and taking up jobs. Here is Sarah describing her job at a firm:

An architects firm and as dull as ditchwater….When I first went into an office about five years ago my aunt…warned me to be careful about men, all in capitals, if you know what I mean. Some of these scaremongers should work in offices themselves. They’d soon lose some of their illusions. They get their ideas from the magazines or the lending libraries, where the employer’s middle name is always wolf, and he’s always dying to seduce the latest recruit. Mr. Rimington is the dullest of bachelors and his partner about as exciting as a pudding when the water’s got in. …If you want to ensure your daughter or niece achieving a blameless old age, put her into an office.” (67-68).

On a more bleak side, there are many orphans or people left without family members. Gilbert, in fact, mentions Germans being killed in British air-raids:

Oh well, she doesn’t know anyone, and she doesn’t seem to have any relations. As a matter of fact, I believe they were all wiped out by a bomb, one of ours, I’m afraid, in 1944” (9).

All in all, this was a good thriller with the tension becoming unbearable at times.However, I did miss the knock-out punch in the end that a Gilbert mystery has.


First Line: IN THE SUMMER OF 1948 a young woman called Greta Mannheim, who was employed as a housekeeper by a Mrs. Derry, of London, S.W. 7 went for a fortnight’s holiday, ostensibly to Torquay, and did not return.

Title: Lady-Killer

Author: Anthony Gilbert

Publication Details: London: Collins (The Crime Club), 1951.

First Published: 1951

Pages: 252

Other books read of the same author: The Clock in the Hatbox, Death Knocks Three Times


The book might be available in libraries or second-hand book shops. I borrowed it from a library [F.G.A 17A]


Submitted for the Vintage Mystery Challenge. (Malicious Men)

Also submitted for the following challenges: 52 Books in 52 Weeks, 2013 Genre Variety, 2013 Mystery/ Crime, 2013 Women, British Books, European Reading, Let Me Count the Ways, Library Books, What countries have I visited.

19 thoughts on “Wolf! Wolf!: Anthony Gilbert’s Lady-Killer

  1. A lonely, helpless woman in the clutch of an apparently loving/caring, but sinister, man in a secluded spot appears to have been a favorite plot device of Gilbert and even the ending missing the knock-out punch of the first part of the story fits! Exactly like Something Nasty in the Woodshed and Die in the Dark. Thanks for the interesting review, Neer.


  2. Thanks TomCat. The Mysteries that I have read of Gilbert's – Clock in the Hatbox, and Death Knocks Three times do not have this kind of scenario. They are wonderful whodunnits where the end leaves you reeling.I am trying to read a few more books of Gilbert. She has really been THE FIND.Hope you visit again.


  3. It does seem like that. 🙂 Very happy that some space is being devoted to this shamefully neglected writer.Thanks for the visit. Hope you come again.


  4. You have convinced me to include an Anthony Gilbert book for the Vintage Mystery challenge this year. Very nice review, and I have checked out the other two from 2012. I have four books by this author in old editions and most of them are falling apart. They will be hard to read.


  5. Thanks Tracy K. I am so very happy that you are going to read Gilbert. She should really be read a lot more. Do read the books quickly lest their condition deteriorate further. I kept Du Maurier's The King's General on my shelf for so long that when I read it last year, it was virtually falling apart.What are the titles that you have?


  6. Unfortunately not Tracy though perhaps Death Takes a Redhead was made into a movie.However, The Passing Tramp is going to do a write-up on Murder Comes Home. That would be interesting to read.


  7. Please don't apologise Gilion. It must be very tough reading all the reviews posted. Thanks for hosting the challenge once again.You are absolutely right. The vintage mystery challenge has put so many books on my Wishlist.:)


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.